How do I fix the Controller Settings loosing the ELEMENT SHIFT WHEEL action?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/760bc/760bc58032442cf810b9406937758355783af6e0" alt="How do I fix the Controller Settings loosing the ELEMENT SHIFT WHEEL action? - Casting disc of modern car How do I fix the Controller Settings loosing the ELEMENT SHIFT WHEEL action? - Casting disc of modern car"
The game involves accessing 8 Elements to cast spells. When you use a gamepad to play the game, the 8 elements are accessed by your four face buttons for the first four elements, then holding the L1 Bumper for the next four.
This 'shift' action also allows editing of the four MAGICKA quick slot spells.
Sometime last night while playing I lost this action. The remainder action, INTERACT, still works with the same button. The shift action is gone.
By gone I mean the game seems to have forgotten it exists. Rebinding it does nothing. It shows the STEAM key instead of whatever I bind it to. This problem continues using a gamepad, using a ps4 controller, after reinstalling magicka, after disabling and re-enabling both generic and ps4 controller options in steam, and after deleting and re-downloading the built in controller configs. I'm going to reinstall steam now after I post this.
Any other ideas?
Pictures about "How do I fix the Controller Settings loosing the ELEMENT SHIFT WHEEL action?"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ed29a/ed29a0053101228dd30f67c3ef8017e0b5be96ca" alt="How do I fix the Controller Settings loosing the ELEMENT SHIFT WHEEL action? - Closeup of bicycle transmission system with metal chain on hydraulic disk brake on wheel How do I fix the Controller Settings loosing the ELEMENT SHIFT WHEEL action? - Closeup of bicycle transmission system with metal chain on hydraulic disk brake on wheel"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c75dc/c75dc8c20b9b7cf58c3a92bc41407106e570b066" alt="How do I fix the Controller Settings loosing the ELEMENT SHIFT WHEEL action? - Disk brake in car service workshop How do I fix the Controller Settings loosing the ELEMENT SHIFT WHEEL action? - Disk brake in car service workshop"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b842d/b842dd207f11b67e1482a4a5d2dcbf21a3656dcc" alt="How do I fix the Controller Settings loosing the ELEMENT SHIFT WHEEL action? - Network cables as supply for work of system How do I fix the Controller Settings loosing the ELEMENT SHIFT WHEEL action? - Network cables as supply for work of system"
How do I reset my controller settings on my computer?
Find your controller and right-click it. Select \u201cGame Controller Settings\u201d from the drop-down menu. Select \u201cProperties\u201d from the new window. On the \u201cSettings\u201d tab, select \u201cReset to Default.\u201dHow do I fix my controller settings on steam?
To do this, please follow these steps:How do I configure my steam controller?
How do I enable Steam Controller Configuration?How do I change my steam link buttons?
When you launch the Steam Link app without a controller, touch controls are automatically available. button in the upper left corner. This allows you to change mouse mode, and show, hide, and layout on-screen touch controls. For more information, select the relevant section below.The *SECRET* Controller Settings Pros Have Been Hiding… (Scroll Wheel Reset Speeds On Controller)
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Erik Mclean, Alfin Auzikri, jae park, Brett Sayles